Alina Lopez and her friend Avi Love are hanging out and decide to try their take on the Bird Box Challenge. They begin with Alina taking off her clothes and letting Avi blindfold her so she can try to get dressed without vision. Alina’s brother, Codey Steele, walks in on the girls in the middle of their game and instead of making his presence known he decides to fap it out. Avi knows Codey is there, but instead of ratting him out to Alina she, too, gets naked and blindfolds herself to join Alina in searching for her clothes while Codey watches. The girls have failed the first challenge they’ve set for themselves, but they’re not about to admit defeat. Avi suggests trying a sex toy while blindfolded. Once again Alina goes first and Avi catches Codey spying on them. This time Avi confronts Codey, but instead of telling him off she tells him she thinks he’s hot and should be part of the challenge. They return to the room together, where Avi tells Alina that she’s going to use a different toy. Little does Alina know that the new toy is her stepbrother’s hardon. Alina is loving it until she realizes it’s a real cock and pulls her blindfold down to find her stepbrother. Too bd for Alina that Codey has a really nice dick that hits all the right spots. Alina eventually decides that it feels too good to stop, at which point Avi gets to join them for a threesome. Avi and Alina take turns feasting on each other’s pussies as Codey bangs them both. Alina is even enjoying it right up until Codey doesn’t bother to pull out before filling her with a creampie of cum.

Ryan Driller is too busy studying for the bar exam to put up with his stepdaughter’s shit. When Emma Hix decides to blast music to practice being a DJ while Ryan is studying, Ryan tells her to turn it down. Emma sasses him and taunts him with her certified nubile body, but Ryan leaves. Emma isn’t about to take her daddy turning her down, so she goes back to playing loud music and then pops her little titties out of her shirt to really reel Ryan in. Ryan is doing oaky at turning down hist stepdaughter’s advances until Emma points out his hard dick. Practically before Ryan knows it, Emma is on her knees with his stiffie in her mouth. She’s masterful at sucking cock, which leaves Ryan way too turned on to say no when Emma turns around and offers her big booty for a doggy style pussy pounding. Ryan fills his hands with his daughter’s ass as Emma rocks in time to meet every stroke. When Ryan takes Emma’s place on the bench, his horny stepdaughter climbs onto his fuck stick to ride him in her tight tiny pussy. Her bald snatch throbs as she turns around to ride Ryan reverse cowgirl style until she gets herself off. Then Emma swaps spots with her stepdaddy so he can bang her until he pops a creampie in her greedy snatch.

Scarlett Mae and her friend Kiara Cole are getting ready for an Easter party when their giggles attract Ricky Spanish’s attention. He bursts into Scarlett’s room and tries to ask his stepsister and her friend when the party is starting. Scarlett makes it clear that Ricky needs to get out because he’s not invited to anything. Later, Ricky gets back at the girls by coloring his balls like an Easter egg and putting them in a basket for them to lick. He hides beneath a blanket and waits for the girls to come in. They follow the instructions and lick the eggs, but their treat is salty, not sweet. While the girls are discussing the egg, Ricky shifts so his dick is in the basket. When Kiara spies it, she suggests that they take turns sucking it. They both assume that it’s Kiara’s boyfriend since they’ve previously discussed having a threesome. Eventually Scarlett wants more, so she pushes her teddy’s crotch aside and hops on for a stiffie ride. She keeps it up until she cums, which is when she finally learns that she’s been fucking her stepbrother the whole time. The girls retreat to the bathroom where they collect themselves. They may have been fooled, but Ricky’s hardon has got them both so horny they start making out! Soon Kiara has her face and fingers buried in Scarlett’s juicy twat. They want some D in their lovemaking, though, so they eventually decide to go back to the living room to give Ricky his lucky day. Faced with a threesome, Ricky plays stud to both his sister and her friend until finally blowing his load in his stepsis’s fuck hole. She claims she’s not on birth control, which freaks Ricky out and leaves both girls laughing that they’ve gotten the final word in their strangely sexual prank war.

Whitney Wright is home from her first semester of college and all she wants to do is crash in her room. When she walks in, though, she finds everything changed. Her stepbrother Ricky Spanish has moved in while she was away! When Ricky comes out of the bathroom and confronts his stepsis, Whitney makes it clear that she’s not going to give up her room without a fight. She tries to make him uncomfortable by taking off her clothes, but Ricky matches her every step of the way. By the time Whitney is down to her underwear, Ricky’s dick is out and hard. She likes the look of his cock, but she’s too committed to back down now. Hopping onto the bed, Whitney starts masturbating to scare her stepbro away. Ricky begins stroking it, but Whitney is prepared to raise the stakes. Crawling across the bed, she opens her mouth to take his dick inside. Soon she’s stroking and sucking in an effort to freak Ricky out. Ricky enjoys the impromptu BJ, but he has something even hotter in mine. Announcing that it’s his turn, Ricky turns Whitney around and pulls her thong down so he can sink balls deep into that greedy twat. In return, Whitney climbs on top to ride Ricky’s stiffie. Then he flips her onto her back so he can take her from above. He pounds into her until he can’t wait another moment to cum. Driving himself balls deep, he gives his stepsister a creampie . That pisses her off, but Ricky is the one to lose out on the room when Whitney wipes his cum on him and he freaks out.